Welcome to Hoxton Wealth, the new home of Hoxton Capital
The Cost of Waiting: Why Market Timing Destroys Returns
Hoxton Blog • The Cost of Waiting: Why Market Timing Destroys Returns
Waiting for the “perfect” moment to invest often feels sensible. In reality, it is one of the most expensive habits investors develop.
Markets move quickly. By the time conditions feel comfortable, much of the return has already been captured. History shows that the biggest gains rarely arrive when the outlook looks clear. They tend to appear when confidence is low and the news still feels uncomfortable.
Over the past year, investors have been bombarded with warnings about crashes, AI bubbles and geopolitical risk. That constant noise made staying on the sidelines feel prudent. The problem is that markets do not move in straight lines. Many of the strongest days arrive when sentiment is still fragile, not once uncertainty has passed.
The data makes this very clear. One dollar invested in the S&P 500 since 1950 grew to roughly 415 dollars if you stayed invested. Miss the best 50 days and that falls to around 29 dollars. Miss the best 100 days and you are left with closer to 5 dollars. A relatively small number of days drove the vast majority of long-term returns.
The real message here is simple. The cost of delay is real. Most of those best days were clustered around periods of stress and sharp market declines, when many investors were either out of the market or waiting for clarity. If you only invest once everything looks calm, you risk missing exactly the days that matter most.
2025’s Rally: A Realtime Example
Throughout 2025, headlines were dominated by recession fears, valuation concerns and predictions of an imminent crash. At the same time, global equity markets delivered strong double-digit gains.
The S&P 500, Dow and Nasdaq all finished the year higher, marking one of the rare periods where the S&P 500 rose by at least 15% for three consecutive years.
Many investors stayed on the sidelines waiting for a “better entry point”. Valuations looked high, politics were messy and geopolitical risks felt unavoidable. Some forecasts even suggested a major correction in 2026, encouraging people to wait it out.
Those who delayed missed not just the 2025 rally, but the compounding that comes from being invested through uncertainty.
AI Stocks and the “I’ll Buy After the Pullback” Trap
AI and large technology names offer another clear illustration. Nvidia, for example, faced constant doubts throughout 2025. Concerns ranged from competition and tariffs to questions over whether AI demand was peaking. Despite that, the stock delivered strong market-beating returns.
Investors who decided to wait for the dust to settle often found that prices had already moved on by the time the news turned positive.
The same pattern repeated around earnings seasons. Some investors sold or delayed buying ahead of results, worried about disappointment. In several cases, shares rallied sharply once earnings or guidance improved, rewarding those who stayed invested and penalising those waiting for confirmation.
What the Data Says About Timing
Long-term studies consistently show the same pattern. One analysis of 30 years of S&P 500 data found that staying fully invested captured the full return. Missing just the 10 best days roughly halved returns. Missing 30 of the best days reduced wealth creation by around 83%.
Crucially, close to 78% of those best days occurred during bear markets or in the first two months of a recovery. These are exactly the periods when investor confidence is at its lowest.
The best and worst days in markets also tend to cluster together. Many of the strongest recovery days arrived shortly after the worst ones. Stepping out during periods of stress often means missing the rebound.
Another study covering 2000 to 2024 showed that virtually all the market’s return over that 25-year period came from just 31 days. Miss those days and the overall return was close to zero, despite taking risk for decades. This is the real cost of sitting in cash waiting for things to “calm down”.
|
Period 2000–2024 |
Result |
|
Invested all days |
Positive long-term return |
|
Missed best 31 days |
Net return ≈ 0% (all gains gone) |
Headlines Versus Long-term Plans
The issue is not the news itself, but how investors respond to it.
In 2025, markets climbed a wall of worry. Political uncertainty, tariff concerns and geopolitical shocks were all widely discussed. In one clear example, investors sold after bad news was confirmed, only to watch a policy pause trigger a near 10% rally in a single day, after they had already exited.
If you wait for political clarity, perfect economic data or valuations that everyone agrees are attractive, you often end up watching from the sidelines while markets move higher. In many of these episodes, the most profitable decision was not to outguess the headlines, but to remain invested and let markets do what they have always done over time.
Turning Urgency Into Action
- The cost of delay is real. Each year, a small number of strong days drive a large share of long-term returns.
- Those days tend to arrive when headlines look uncomfortable, not when everything feels settled.
- Waiting for the “right moment” based on news flow risks missing both rallies like 2025 and the early stages of future recoveries.
A more effective approach is to invest once your plan and risk level are clear, then add consistently over time. Markets will rise and fall.
History suggests that time in the market, supported by discipline and diversification, has been far more powerful than trying to pick the perfect entry point.
If you’d like to discuss your financial plan or portfolio, please contact your Hoxton Wealth adviser.
You can also reach our client services team at client.services@hoxtonwealth.com or via WhatsApp on +44 7384 100200.
How Can We Help You?
If you would like to speak to one of our advisers, please get in touch today.
Contact Hoxton Wealth
We are available to discuss how Hoxton Wealth can help you achieve your financial goals. Together, we can help you build a brighter financial future.
